I loved this because every life deserves a lifetime. Every life.
The San Francisco Chronicle is reporting that the judge presiding over the Proposition 8 appeal, Judge Vaughn Walker, is gay:
“The biggest open secret in the landmark trial over same-sex marriage being heard in San Francisco is that the federal judge who will decide the case, Chief U.S. District Judge Vaughn Walker, is himself gay.
Many gay politicians in San Francisco and lawyers who have had dealings with Walker say the 65-year-old jurist, appointed to the bench by President George H.W. Bush in 1989, has never taken pains to disguise – or advertise – his orientation.”
If that is true, it would explain a lot. Why was Judge Walker so eager to break federal court rules against televising hearings? Why was he so eager to deny the defense their first amendment rights by trying to force them to disclose private campaign documents?
Twice now, higher courts have had to intervene in Judge Walker’s court proceedings to check his enthusiasm for tipping the scales of justice.
Could Judge Walker being gay himself have any bearing on his decisions? We’ll never know. As one commenter on this story said:
“He should have recused himself, just to avoid the image of impropriety. As it is, people will always wonder, and assume he made those bad judgments out of an inappropriate personal bias.”
Certainly a judge’s personal life and choices do not HAVE to interfere with his impartiality, however it certainly does color the appearance of his decision.
History will always question his judgment and wonder. No matter what side of the issue you fall on, this information does nothing but cast doubt on the legitimacy of this court and its proceedings.
|URGENT ALERT: Urge Congress to Support Bill to Protect Marriage!
|Breaking news from Washington . . . .
9 U.S. Senators have agreed to co-sponsor a bill that would guarantee the right of DC residents to vote on same-sex marriage.
The bill will be introduced shortly and will complement a similar bill introduced in the House in January. The House bill is HR4430, and I’ll keep you posted when the Senate Bill is introduced and assigned a number.
The next few days are crucial as we meet with legislators and seek support on Capitol Hill! We need your help right now.
Sending Your Letter
When you use the link above to send your email message, you’ll see two letters. If your senator or congressman is one of the existing co-sponsors to the bill, they will receive the “Letter for Co-Sponsors.” Otherwise, your senators and congressman will receive the “Letter for All Others.” Either way, your letter will be going to your own elected officials in Washington. Please take a moment to personalize your letter to let your representatives in Washington know how important this issue is.
Your Voice Makes a Difference!
The Senate leadership just wants this issue to go away, and will do whatever they can to bury it in committee. That’s why every Senator needs to hear from people in his or her own state, urging him to stand up for the voting rights of DC residents.
An out-of-control city council tried to do an end run around the DC Charter, refusing to recognize the rights of DC voters to file an initiative petition on marriage. Regardless of where your representatives stand on same-sex marriage, tell them that we ought not stand for this sort of government abuse against the residents of our nation’s capital.
Tell your Senators and Congressman you want them to publicly stand for marriage and civil rights by co-sponsoring the DC Marriage Initiative Bill / HR4430. Tell them how important this issue is both for the future of marriage and for the rights of everyday citizens trying to stand up against a government machine.
Then tell them you want them to champion this issue, push for a vote, and not let Nancy Pelosi or Harry Reid bury it in some subcommittee!
Then forward this message to friends and family all across the country! Together we can stand up for DC voters and make sure they have a chance to be heard on marriage!
Brian S. Brown
National Organization for Marriage
20 Nassau Street, Suite 242
Princeton, NJ 08542
P.S.: Are you a part of our national grassroots action team? Sign up at TwoMillionForMarriage.com
today to receive regular email alerts and marriage updates from Washington and your own state capital!